Chamber Music

Moments incommunicables

for Guitar, Flute, Clarinet, Violin and Cello

Recording

Note

“The single biggest problem in communication is the illusion that it has taken place.” (George Bernard Shaw)
This piece tries to confront the singularity of an experience and the inability to share and communicate it. The music composed tries to function as a soundtrack of the subconscious, to imagine how these dark places could “sound”. The piece begins with an ungraspable musical experience and later, the “actor” on stage tries to communicate this experience but gradually, the communication and its means become blurred. The abstraction and generalization that are necessary for communication flatten the original experience, leading in the end to a binary, meaningless act of communication.

Few years after writing this piece I found that quote in the beautiful book "Listening" by Jean-Luc Nancy:
"[...] That is why Wittgenstein, after discussing the borderline, or imaginary, experience of hearing a sound separated from its timbre, comes to take timbre as a privileged image of what he calls "private experience", consequently, experience that is not communicable. I would say that timbre is communication of the incommunicable: provided it is understood that the incommunicable is nothing other, in a perfectly logical way, that communication itself [...]"

(Or in the original french: "[...] C'est pourquoi Wittgenstein, après avoir proposé l'expérience limite, ou imaginaire, d'entendre un son séparé de son timbre, en vient à prendre le timbre pour image privilégiée de ce qu'il nomme l’”expérience privée" et, par conséquent, non communicable. Je dirais volontiers que le timbre est la communication de l'incommunicable: à la condition de bien entendu que l'incommunicable n'est rien d'autre, de manière parfaitement logique, que la communication même[...]")

Performances

Mar 01, 2012 Clairmont Hall, Tel Aviv University (Israel)

Ruben Seroussi (Guitar) and "Meitar" ensemble

World premiere
Apr 25, 2012 Grosser Saal, Hochschule für Musik Basel (Switzerland)

Flavio Virzì (Gtr), Sonja Horlacher (Fl), Pablo Barragán Hernández (Cl), Alessio Pianelli (Vcl), Orsolya Sepsi (Vln)

May 30, 2012 Felt Music Club, Rome (Italy)

G.E.R.M.I. Ensemble

Jun 22, 2012 Grosser Saal, Hochschule für Musik Basel (Switzerland)

David Silva (Clarinet), Wiktor Kociuban (Cello), Flavio Virzì (Guitar), Sonja Horlacher (Flute), Orsolya Sepsi (Violin) | Master Diplom Concert

Oct 29, 2016 Contemporary music center, the Israeli conservatory, Tel Aviv (Israel)

"Meitar" Ensemble and Nadav Lev

Nov 23, 2018 Jerusalem Music Center (Israel)

Israel Contemporary Players

Nov 24, 2018 Tel Aviv Museum (Israel)

Israel Contemporary Players

Sep 21, 2019 Great Guild Hall, Tallinn (Estonia)

Sound Plasma Ensemble

Nov 03, 2019 Acker Stadt Palast, Berlin (Germany)

Sound Plasma Ensemble

Sep 14, 2023 Ackermannshof, Basel (Switzerland)

Ruben Mattia Santorsa and Neuverband

Nov 07, 2025 Altes Forsthaus Borstel, Winsen (Germany)

Ensemble L'ART POUR L'ART